侠Liangshen AIailiangshen.com
AI Implementation Workshop · Short topic lessons · Lesson 14

Bidding Responses and Proposal Drafting

Ensure no clauses are missed in hundreds of pages, maintain consistent response language, and have humans write commitment-related content.

Freeabout 10 minNo experience neededWeb lesson + slides + video

This course covers bidding responses and proposal drafting. With hundreds of pages of bidding documents, you must ensure no clauses are missed, maintain consistent language throughout, and produce a draft proposal. However, commitment-related content must be written by humans.

What this lesson covers

  • Scenarios
  • Methods
  • Prompts and Examples
  • Quizzes and Takeaways

01

Scenarios

About 1 minutes

Let's start with a scenarioFictional example; numbers are illustrative

Duochuan Communications · Solution Manager Mo Jiayi

Upon receiving a telecom operator's bidding document, which spans hundreds of pages, each takes about five working days, with four to five bids per quarter.

Common pitfalls: missing clause breakdowns, especially veto clauses; overstating 'compliance'; inconsistent language across chapters.

Qi Lan Intelligence's pre-sales colleague Yi faced hundreds of security questionnaire items, with inconsistent responses and commitments to product capabilities that do not yet exist.

The Dragon Warrior is excellent at breaking down lists and performing pre-matching; however, it has no authority to make commitments.
02

Methods

About 2 minutes

Method: First confirm usability, then break down the list

1
First confirm whether the use of AI is permittedBidding documents often have confidentiality requirements; if not permitted, do not paste the content; if permitted, only process de-identified parts.
2
Break down into three listsMandatory response clauses, suspected veto clauses, and clauses requiring clarification
3
Use the capability library for pre-matchingThe capability library is the company's standard response repository, with each capability linked to a product document number; unmatched items are marked for human writing.
4
Generate the proposal structure and transitional paragraphs firstBackground restatement can be used for drafting; product capabilities, pricing, delivery timelines, and liability for breach of contract must be written by humans.
5
Veto clauses, double-checked by two peopleFor every item marked 'Satisfied', click the source link to verify
Quotation discounts, product roadmaps, and current customer network status are never included.
03

Prompts and Examples

About 4 minutes
Tip

Prompt 1: Break down clauses

Suggested time
Prompt 1 (Break down clauses)
Below is a set of clauses from a bidding document (de-identified, with the client referred to as Client A). Please break them into three lists:
1. Clauses that must be responded to: List each one, keeping the clause number and original text;
2. Suspected veto clauses: Include those with words like 'overdue counts as', 'not satisfied means', 'must', etc. List each one and specify the source text basis;
3. Clauses requiring clarification: For vague or contradictory items, write each as a question.
Rules: Only break down; do not judge whether we can satisfy them; do not merge clauses; copy clause numbers exactly.
Clauses: [Paste]
Clause numbers must match the original text; for each suspected veto clause, you must be able to point to the source text basis.
Tip

Prompt 2: Pre-match using the capability library

Suggested time
Prompt 2 (Pre-match)
Below is the capability library (each with an ID) and a list of broken-down clauses. Please pre-match each item and output a table with columns: Clause Number, Response Suggestion (Satisfied, Partially Satisfied, Not Satisfied, Needs Clarification, Needs Human Writing), Capability ID, and Difference Description.
Rules: 1. 'Satisfied' must include a capability ID; if no ID, write 'To be verified'; do not invent one. 2. If there is a difference from the clause requirements, write 'Partially Satisfied' and describe the difference. 3. Price, discounts, delivery times, and liability for breach of contract are listed as 'Needs Human Writing'. 4. The wording for the same capability across multiple clauses must be consistent.
Capability Library: [Paste]
Clauses: [Paste]
For every item marked 'Satisfied', click the source link to verify the clause requirements against the product documentation.

Example: Item 4 is the key to this lessonFictional example; numbers are illustrative

Incorrect writing: Marked as 'Satisfied'

Item 4: The bidder must commit to on-site response 7x24 hours, with a response time of no more than 1 hour. The capability library states on-site arrival time is within 4 hours. Marking this as 'Satisfied' is an exaggeration.

Correct response

  • Item 2: Suspected veto clause, referred to the project manager for double-check
  • Item 4: Partially satisfied, specify the difference between 4 hours and 1 hour; the commitment is decided by the human and sales lead
  • Items 1 and 5: Needs Human Writing
  • Item 3: Satisfied, attached CAP-03, DOC-12
Clicking the source for every 'Satisfied' item is for this very reason.

Common deviations and remedies

Writing 'Partially Satisfied' as 'Satisfied'

Remedy: Require the difference to be written out; verify every 'Satisfied' item by clicking the source.

Fabricating product capabilities

Remedy: If there is no capability ID, mark it as 'To Be Verified'.

Missed dissection of veto clauses

Remedy: Double-check with another person; also have it count the clauses containing 'deemed', 'bid rejection', or 'must', and compare with your own search results.

It included price or delivery time

Remedy: Delete; price, delivery time, and liability for breach are decided by humans and legal.

If the wording is inconsistent, have it list how the same capability is phrased in different clauses, and let humans unify it.
04

Quizzes and Takeaways

About 3 minutes

Three quick questions to check yourself

Question 1: Who writes the price response?

Answer B.Price, delivery time, and liability for breach are decided by humans, legal, and the sales head; it does not write them.

Question 2: How do you mark a clause that has no source in the capability library?

Answer B.For items with no source, mark as 'To Be Verified' or 'Needs Human Input'; do not let it invent a capability.

Takeaway from this lesson: Four key phrases

  1. First, confirm whether the document allows the use of AI; if not, do not paste it
  2. Break down into three lists: mandatory responses, potential veto clauses, and items needing clarification
  3. Each satisfied item must have a product document ID; if missing, write 'To Be Verified'
  4. Price, discounts, delivery time, and liability for breach are written by humans
Show the full transcript (video narration)
Bidding Responses and Proposal Drafting

This course covers bidding responses and proposal drafting. With hundreds of pages of bidding documents, you must ensure no clauses are missed, maintain consistent language throughout, and produce a draft proposal. However, commitment-related content must be written by humans. Let's start with a scenario.

Let's start with a scenario

Let's start with a scenario, which is fictional, and the numbers are merely illustrative. Mo Jiayi, Solution Manager at Duochuan Communications, received a telecom operator's bidding document spanning hundreds of pages, taking about five working days per bid, with four to five bids per quarter. Common pitfalls include missing clause breakdowns, especially veto clauses; overstating 'compliance'; and inconsistent language across chapters. Qi Lan Intelligence's pre-sales colleague Yi faced hundreds of security questionnaire items, with inconsistent responses and commitments to product capabilities that do not yet exist. The Dragon Warrior is excellent at breaking down lists and performing pre-matching; however, it has no authority to make commitments.

Method: First confirm usability, then break down the list

The process has five steps. Step 1: Confirm whether the document allows the use of AI. Bidding documents often have confidentiality requirements; if not allowed, do not include them. If allowed, only process the de-identified parts. Step 2: Split into three lists: clauses that must be responded to, suspected veto clauses, and clauses requiring clarification. Step 3: Use the capability library for pre-matching. For matched items, write suggested responses and sources; for unmatched items, mark them for human writing. Step 4: Draft the structure and transition paragraphs of the proposal first; product capabilities, pricing, delivery times, and liability for breach of contract are written by humans. Step 5: Double-check veto clauses with two people; for every item marked 'Satisfied', click the source link to verify. Quotation discounts, product roadmaps, and current customer network status are never included.

Prompt 1: Break down clauses

The first prompt is to break down clauses. Ask it to split them into three lists: those that must be responded to, suspected veto clauses, and those requiring clarification. For each suspected veto clause, specify the source text basis. The rules are: only break down, do not judge whether we can satisfy them, do not merge clauses, and copy clause numbers exactly.

Prompt 2: Pre-match using the capability library

The second prompt is to pre-match using the capability library. Each response suggestion must include a capability ID. If there is no ID, write 'To be verified'; do not invent a capability. If there is a difference from the clause, write 'Partially Satisfied' and describe the difference. Price, discounts, delivery times, and liability for breach of contract are all listed as 'Needs Human Writing'.

Example: Item 4 is the key to this lesson

Look at an example, where the numbers are illustrative. Item 4 requires the bidder to commit to on-site response 7x24 hours, with a response time of no more than 1 hour. The capability library states on-site arrival time is within 4 hours. If marked as 'Satisfied', it is an exaggeration. The correct response is 'Partially Satisfied', specifying the difference, with the commitment decided by the human and sales lead. Item 2 is a suspected veto clause, referred to the project manager for double-check. Items 1 and 5 need human writing. Item 3 is satisfied, with capability and document IDs attached.

Common deviations and remedies

There are four common deviations. First, writing 'satisfied' for partial satisfaction; the remedy is to require the difference to be stated and to click through to verify the source for each satisfied item. Second, fabricating product capabilities; the remedy is that if there is no capability ID, mark it as 'To Be Verified'. Third, missing the dissection of veto clauses; the remedy is double-checking with another person, and having it separately count clauses containing words like 'deemed', 'bid rejection', or 'must', and compare with your own search results. Fourth, it included price or delivery time; the remedy is deletion, as price, delivery time, and liability for breach are decided by humans and legal. If the wording is inconsistent, have it list how the same capability is phrased in different clauses, and let humans unify it.

Quiz Question 1

Let's do the quiz. Question 1: Who writes the price response? A, It writes it, then sales reviews it. B, Humans and legal, along with the sales head, make the final decision; it does not write it. C, Automatically generated by the capability library. The answer is B. Price, delivery time, and liability for breach are decided by humans, legal, and the sales head; it does not write them.

Quiz Question 2

Question 2: How do you mark a clause that has no source in the capability library? A, Write 'Satisfied'; its judgment is usually reliable. B, Write 'To Be Verified' or 'Needs Human Input'; do not let it invent a capability. C, Delete this clause; no response is needed. The answer is B. For items with no source, mark as 'To Be Verified' or 'Needs Human Input'; do not let it invent a capability.

Takeaway from this lesson: Four key phrases

Let's review. Takeaway from this lesson: Four key phrases. First, confirm whether the document allows the use of AI; if not, do not paste it. Second, break down into three lists: mandatory responses, potential veto clauses, and items needing clarification. Third, each satisfied item must have a product document ID; if missing, write 'To Be Verified'. Fourth, price, discounts, delivery time, and liability for breach are written by humans.

Next step: Break down a set of clauses from your hand

Next, select five de-identified clauses and break them down according to the three lists. Identify potentially vetoing clauses and have a second person review them. This video's narration is AI-generated. Thank you for watching.