侠Liangshen AIailiangshen.com
AI Implementation Workshop · Core lessons · Lesson 2

Speak Clearly: State, Supplement, Ask, Explore

The same task yields different results when explained fully versus partially

Freeabout 60 minNo experience neededWeb lesson + slides + video

In the previous lesson, we met Dragon Warrior and learned what it can do. In this lesson, we will learn how to communicate with it: clearly brief a task, incorporate your internal standards, inquire about unfamiliar business areas, and ask it to uncover blind spots we might have missed.

By the end of this lesson, you can

  • Clearly brief a task: specify what to do, who the audience is, the background context, and the required format and length.
  • Add one internal standard at a time, and verify that other details haven't been inadvertently altered.
  • Inquire about an unfamiliar business area and create a quick-reference card.
  • Ask it to uncover blind spots and obtain a list of counterarguments.

Takeaways: Briefing Four Elements Card, Unfamiliar Business Quick-Reference Card, Counterargument List

Video version: about 15 min

Narration is AI-generated. The video plays on YouTube; the chapter buttons above jump to the matching places. You can skip the video and scroll down to read.
01

Opening and Assignment Review

About 5 minutes

A Case Study: Lin Yue

Lin Yue, Administrative Specialist (fictional example)

She asked Dragon Warrior to draft a meeting notice.

The result was a generic, bland notice that no one wanted to read.

It even fabricated the time and location.

The reason is simple: she only provided half the information.

It only completes the prompt with the most generic version possible.

How to Review Last Session's Homework: Read the Entire Class List First

1
Categorize FirstBefore class, remove names from the full class list and ask the Dragon Warrior to group them into three or four categories.
2
Then, Read Three ExamplesSelect the three clearest examples, including the original text, time spent, and number of iterations.
3
Finally, Point Out FlawsCommon flaws: mixing desired outcomes with current tasks, and using vague time estimates like 'a long time.'
The candidate list should reflect what you currently spend time on, not what you hope the AI will do.
02

Concept: The Four Elements of Briefing

About 4 minutes

State the Four Elements

What to Do

One verb plus one object, e.g., 'Draft a meeting rescheduling notice.'

Who It's For

Who the audience is, their level of understanding, and their concerns.

What Context

Existing facts, cause and effect, and non-negotiable constraints.

What Format and Length

Number of paragraphs or bullet points, word count, whether a title is needed, and the desired tone.

If you omit a sentence, it will fill in the blank with the most generic version.

A Metaphor: Division of Labor

1
Courier DeliveryIf you only tell a courier to deliver a package, they will ask for the address and recipient. The Dragon Warrior does not ask; it delivers based on the most likely assumption.
2
General Knowledge vs. Company RulesIt knows how to write a notice; it does not know your company's specific conventions. Providing these details fills in the gaps.
3
State, Supplement, Ask, ExploreBe clear, fill in the standards, ask about unfamiliar details, and uncover blind spots.

The more specific your identity description, the greater the difference in results.

Vague

"You are an administrative staff member."

  • A single job title is insufficient.
  • It can only guess what kind of person you want.

Include methods.

"You are an administrative specialist with ten years of experience serving a 12-person department. Your habit is to state the time in the first sentence, put the reason later, and avoid pleasantries."

  • Clearly state how many years of experience and who you serve.
  • Then describe how the person works.
The middle tier is specific: clearly state how many years of experience and who you serve. Borrow the identity from the position, not from a real person.
03

Demonstration: Partial vs. Clear Briefing

About 10 minutes

Example: Two versions of the same task.

Version 1: Incomplete
Help me write a meeting notice.
(Example) A template notice: 'Colleagues, please attend on time.' Time and location are left blank, or it generates them itself.
Version 2: Clear
Please help me draft a meeting rescheduling notice. Cover four elements in one sentence each: what to do, who it's for, background, and format/length.
(Example) A notice of about 100 words, complete with time, location, reason, and reminders, with a steady tone.
Version 2 has four additional sentences, corresponding exactly to the four elements.

Compare the two versions and count.

Usually, the most useful parts are 'who it's for' and 'background,' as they determine what is included and what is excluded.
Tip

Version 3: Adding Standards

Suggested time
Version 3 (sent after Version 2)
Revise it again: Our company's notification habit is to state the new time clearly in the first sentence, and put the reason in the following sentence. Use 'Hello, colleagues' as the salutation, not 'Respected'. Please rewrite according to this habit, keeping the rest of the content unchanged.
Expectation: The new version starts with the new time, the salutation is changed, and the rest of the content remains basically the same.

If some standards are unclear, let it make a mistake first.

Just say 'concise and appropriate'.

  • It can only guess.
  • The first sentence is mostly polite greetings, or it states the reason first.

Give it an example.

'This week's regular meeting is moved to Friday at 10:00 AM in Conference Room 3.' The next sentence states the reason, within 60 characters.

  • The first sentence is the new time.
Abstractly saying 'concise and appropriate' forces it to guess; giving it an example allows it to follow.

Industry Version: Night-time Change Notification

Hong Zhiyuan, Network Operations Engineer at Duchuan Communications (fictional example)

Send a night-time change notification to Client A's operations team.

Version 2 states clearly: Upgrade equipment 01 to 04 from 2:00 AM to 4:00 AM this Saturday, with an approximate 15-minute interruption (for illustration). The rollback person in charge is the shift supervisor.

Version 3 adds standards: The first sentence states the change window, the second sentence states the impact scope, and the rollback person in charge is on a separate line.

In real work, equipment numbers and client names are replaced with codes before posting.

The extent of the impact and how to rollback determine what needs to be written in the notification.
04

Practice A through D

About 31 minutes

Exercise A: Supplement, adding the standards in your mind

1
ShortenUse only one verb at a time; after making the change, check if there are any passive constructions elsewhere.
2
Front-loadFor example: Front-load the first sentence.
3
DeleteExample: Remove polite filler phrases
4
Change the toneUse the job title to set the tone, not a real person's voice
5
Leave blank for completionExample: Leave this blank for completion; do not fabricate content
The Dragon Warrior's first draft is usually 70% good; the missing 30% is your standard. Add only one sentence at a time.
Tip

Exercise A: Prompt A1 and A2

Suggested time
A1: Remove polite filler phrases from the beginning
Here is the first draft of an email I wrote to a client. Please do only one thing: remove the polite opening and change it to directly state, 'The attachment is the next quarter's pricing proposal.' Do not change a single word of the rest of the content. After making the change, mark your edits with 【】.
A2: Add the pricing validity period (send this after completing the previous step)
Add one more standard: Include a sentence in the body stating, 'The pricing is valid until the end of this month.' Keep the rest of the content unchanged from the previous version, and similarly mark your new edits with 【】.
Expectation: Make only one change at a time; after A3, you will have a complete new email along with a change log.

Zhou Kai's pricing email

Zhou Kai, Sales Operations (Yuanfan Technology, fictional example)

Draft opening: Dear Mr. Wang, hello! Thank you for your continued trust and support of Yuanfan Technology.

Standard 1: The opening should not be so polite; state the matter directly.

Standard 2: You must specify that the pricing is valid until the end of the month.

Standard 3: Remind the client that they can schedule a 20-minute call for clarification.

Make three revisions, adding one standard each time. Finally, compare the text word for word to see if anything was inadvertently altered.

Exercise A: Check standards and common deviations

Common deviation: It inadvertently deleted 'Sincerely yours.' The fix is to reply: 'Please restore the closing 'Sincerely yours' without changing anything else.'

Exercise B: Ask, Shallow Questions vs. Deep Questions

Shallow Question

"How do I conduct campus recruitment?"

  • Mostly a generic, encyclopedic answer
  • Unclear about what to do first and what to do later

Deep Question (Steps 1–4 of Prompt B)

  • Teach only the most critical 20%, including sequence and trade-offs
  • Eight cards, one flowchart, three frameworks
  • The rest consists of specific steps, timelines, and role assignments
3-Minute Check: Count how many specific steps, timelines, and role assignments the deep question adds.
Tip

Prompt B: Five Steps to Get You Started

Suggested time
Prompt B (only steps 1–4 are provided in class; step 5 is saved for when you say "Start testing me")
I am Xu Jing, an HR Specialist (you can replace this with your own role), and I need to handle next year's [campus recruitment] for my company, but I have no prior experience. Please guide me through the following five steps:
1. Teach only the most critical 20%—the content that, if mastered, allows you to handle 80% of the work. Skip the peripheral details.
2. Create eight knowledge cards from this 20%. Each card should include: a name, a one-sentence explanation, and a workplace example.
3. Draw a text-based end-to-end flowchart, with one step per line, connected by arrows.
4. Provide three practical thinking frameworks, explaining when to use each.
5. Do not end directly. Instead, test me one question at a time: ask one question, wait for my answer, then provide feedback and the next question, for a total of five questions.

Please complete steps 1 through 4 first. Step 5 will be executed only after I say "Start testing me."
Expectation: Eight cards, one text flowchart, three frameworks; after saying "Start testing me," it will present one question at a time.

The Crash Course Card consists of four components

Eight Cards

Each card contains a name, a one-sentence explanation, and a workplace example

One Chart

A text-based flowchart, with one step per line, connected by arrows

Three Frameworks

Each explains when to use it

Test Me One Question at a Time

Present one question at a time; wait for the answer before presenting the next

Three Universal Follow-Up Questions: Why do it this way? What if the conditions changed...? Please give a specific example.

Exercise C: Dig Deeper, Ask It to Shift Perspectives

Dialogue 1: Shallow Question
I plan to change our weekly project status meetings to biweekly, using text updates in between. Is this a good idea?
(Prompt) It starts by going along with you: This is a thought worth considering...
Dialogue 2: Ask It to Play the Opposition
Please play the role of someone opposing this idea. List the five strongest arguments against it, explaining the actual consequences for each. Do not agree with me, and do not start by affirming before pivoting.
(Prompt) List the opposing arguments directly, each with specific consequences.
If you want the truth, switch to a question format that prevents it from simply agreeing.

List of Opposition Arguments: Common Examples

1
Problems are exposed later
2
Cross-departmental dependencies are delayed
3
New members struggle to keep up
4
Status updates become a mere formality
5
Ad-hoc decisions lack clear ownership
Opposing views are for inspiration, not conclusion. You make the final call on whether to adopt them.

Digging for Blind Spots: Three-Layer Questioning

Project Manager He Lei (Fictional Example)

Layer 1, Surface: This is about reducing meetings.

Layer 2, The Real Issue: Information needs to flow timely.

Layer 3, The Assumption: Everyone will update the shared spreadsheet on time and carefully.

Finally, ask: What happens if the assumption in Layer 3 is false?

Before making big decisions, ask: Is this choice actually solving the real problem?

Exercise D: Five Fragmented Questions, Combined into One Statement

Five Fragmented QuestionsWrite a notice; about the Mid-Autumn Festival holiday; three days off; remind everyone to secure valuables; tone is relaxed, under 100 characters
→
Combining Four ElementsClarify what you want, who it's for, the context, and the format and length.
→
Send it all at once.Get a ready-to-use version in one go; fill in any required dates yourself.
The longer the conversation, the more likely it is to miss details. Asking clearly once saves you from asking ten times back and forth.
Tip

Reference Answer: Ask clearly in one go.

Suggested time
Lin Yue's combined single instruction (example):
Please draft a Mid-Autumn Festival holiday notice. Audience: All company employees. They only need to know the holiday schedule and precautions. Context: The company has a three-day Mid-Autumn holiday, [insert specific holiday and makeup work dates here], and please secure valuables before the holiday. Format and length: Under 100 words, relaxed tone, no exclamation marks, no title.
Check: Sending it once yields a ready-to-use version, all four elements are present, and there are no blanks left for the AI to guess.
05

Assignment

About 5 minutes

Assignment: Instruction Cards, Crash-Course Cards, and Optional Checklist

Before submitting, remove sensitive information: keep it under 200 words, and exclude client privacy, unpublished data, passwords, and contract text.
06

Buffer Time and Wrap-up

About 5 minutes

Three quick questions to check yourself

Question 1: Quiz Question 1: What are the four elements of a summary?

Answer A.If any element is missing, the system will automatically fill it in, usually with the most generic or even fabricated content.

Question 2: Quiz Question 2: How should you ask to obtain genuine, differing opinions?

Answer B.It tends to agree with you. Explicitly asking it to take the opposing side helps uncover blind spots you might have missed.

Key Takeaways

  1. The Four Elements of a Brief: What to do, who the audience is, the context, and the required format and length.
  2. Add only one sentence at a time, then check other sections to ensure nothing was inadvertently changed.
  3. Onboarding for unfamiliar tasks using Quick-Start Cards: eight cards, one flowchart, and three frameworks.
  4. Ask it to take the opposing side to uncover blind spots you hadn't considered.
Show the full transcript (video narration)
Speak Clearly

Welcome to Lesson 2 of the AI Implementation Workshop. In the previous lesson, we met Dragon Warrior and learned what it can do. In this lesson, we will learn how to communicate with it: clearly brief a task, incorporate your internal standards, inquire about unfamiliar business areas, and ask it to uncover blind spots we might have missed.

After completing this lesson, you will be able to:

After completing this lesson, you will be able to do four things. First, clearly brief a task, including what to do, who the audience is, the background context, and the required format and length. Second, add one internal standard at a time, and verify that other details haven't been inadvertently altered. Third, inquire about an unfamiliar business area and create a quick-reference card. Fourth, ask it to uncover blind spots and obtain a list of counterarguments.

A Case Study: Lin Yue

Let's look at an example. Lin Yue, an administrative specialist, asked the Dragon Warrior to draft a meeting notice. The result was a bland, generic notice that no one wanted to read. Worse, it fabricated the time and location. She was dissatisfied, and for one reason: she only provided half the instructions. Today, we will provide the other half.

How to Review Last Session's Homework: Read the Entire Class List First

Last session's homework was to list your five most time-consuming tasks this week. Before class, the instructor removes names from the full list and asks the Dragon Warrior to categorize them. In class, only three of the clearest original examples are read aloud, followed by a discussion of common flaws. The candidate list should reflect what you currently spend time on, not what you hope the AI will do.

State the Four Elements

Instructions are what you say to the Dragon Warrior. Clear instructions lead to accurate results. There are four elements: What to do (one verb plus one object), Who it's for (audience, understanding, concerns), What context (existing facts and constraints), and What format and length (paragraphs, word count, title, tone). If you omit a sentence, it will fill in the blank, usually with the most generic version.

A Metaphor: Division of Labor

Use an analogy to understand. If you just tell a courier to deliver a package, they will inevitably ask for the address, recipient, and time. The Dragon Warrior doesn't ask; it simply delivers based on the most likely scenario, and you only realize it's wrong after receiving it. So, make sure your instructions are complete before you start. It knows how to write a standard notice, but it doesn't know your company's specific habits. 'Filling in' means providing these internal rules. The four key words for this lesson are: State, Supplement, Ask, and Uncover.

The more specific your identity description, the greater the difference in results.

Instructions often include a phrase like 'You are...'. The more specific you are, the closer the output matches your needs. Consider three levels. Vaguely stating a job title provides insufficient information. Clearly stating years of experience and who you serve makes it specific. Adding how this person works makes it useful. For example: 'Habit is to state the time in the first sentence, put the reason later, and avoid pleasantries.' Borrow the identity from the position, not from a real person.

Example: Two versions of the same task.

This example uses fictional information. The scenario is administrative specialist Lin Yue notifying department colleagues that the weekly meeting is rescheduled this week. When you do this yourself, first check your company's AI usage guidelines. Do not paste client privacy, unpublished data, or passwords. If you must paste sensitive data, anonymize it first. Version 1 only says: 'Help me write a meeting notice.' It either asks follow-up questions or writes a template notice with blank or fabricated time and location. Version 2 states each of the four elements, resulting in a complete notice. Comparing the two versions, Version 2 has four additional sentences.

Compare the two versions and count.

Compare the two versions and count. Version 2 has four additional sentences, corresponding to the four elements. Ask yourself: Which sentence was most helpful? Usually, it's 'who it's for' and 'background,' as they determine what is included and what is excluded. With the same Dragon Warrior, different inputs yield different outputs. The best practice, ultimately, is organizing the input information effectively.

Version 3: Adding Standards

Version 3 adds standards. Go back to Version 2 and send this sentence: Our company's notification habit is to state the new time clearly in the first sentence, put the reason afterwards, and use 'Hello, colleagues' as the salutation. When it answers, don't just wait idly; think about the next step first. Once you get the new version, read only the first sentence and compare it with the first sentence of Version 2; there is no need to read the full text.

If some standards are unclear, let it make a mistake first.

Some standards are unclear in words. Saying 'concise and appropriate' forces it to guess. The solution is to let it make a mistake first, then give it an example. On the left, just saying 'concise and appropriate' means the first sentence is mostly polite greetings or states the reason first. On the right, give it an example: 'This week's regular meeting is moved to Friday at 10:00 AM in Conference Room 3,' followed by the reason. It will then follow this format. If the first draft that comes out before class happens to be correct, say: 'It got lucky this time; don't expect it to be correct every time.'

Industry Version: Night-time Change Notification

Students in the technology industry can work on this version. The company's data red lines are placed at the beginning: source code, keys, unreleased products, and client network data must not be posted in public AI applications. The material for this exercise is fictional. Hong Zhiyuan from Duchuan Communications needs to send a night-time change notification to Client A's operations team. Version 2 clearly states the time, equipment, impact, and rollback. Version 3 adds standards: The first sentence states the change window, the second sentence states the impact scope, and the rollback person in charge is on a separate line.

Exercise A: Supplement, adding the standards in your mind

Exercise A: Refine your standards. The Dragon Warrior's first draft is usually 70% good; the missing 30% is your standard. There is only one method: add only one sentence at a time, then check other sections to ensure they weren't inadvertently altered. The only five verbs you may use are: shorten, move to the front, delete, change tone, and leave blank for completion. Use only one at a time. For example, move the first sentence to the front, delete polite filler phrases, and leave this section blank for completion; do not fabricate content.

Exercise A: Prompt A1 and A2

The material is fictional. Zhou Kai, in Sales Operations, needs to write a follow-up email to an existing client regarding next quarter's pricing. He has three standards in mind: the opening should not be so polite; state the matter directly; specify that the pricing is valid until the end of the month; and remind the client that they can schedule a 20-minute call for clarification. The first standard is implemented using prompt A1, which deletes the polite phrases without changing any other words. The second standard is added using A2, specifying the validity period, changing only that one part.

Zhou Kai's pricing email

Let's look at the first draft of Zhou Kai's email. The opening is: 'Dear Mr. Wang, hello! Thank you for your continued trust and support of Yuanfan Technology.' Zhou Kai has three standards in mind: state the matter directly in the opening; specify that the pricing is valid until the end of the month; and remind the client that they can schedule a 20-minute call for clarification. These three standards are added in three separate steps, one standard at a time.

Exercise A: Check standards and common deviations

Check three things. All three standards have been implemented. The salutation, closing, and attachment notes have not been touched; compare them word for word. The final change log must match the visual comparison. A common deviation is that it inadvertently deletes the closing 'Sincerely yours.' The remedy is to reply: 'Please restore the closing 'Sincerely yours' without changing anything else.' The more you change, the harder it is to verify, so add only one sentence at a time.

Exercise B: Ask, Shallow Questions vs. Deep Questions

The scenario for Exercise B is: HR Specialist Xu Jing needs to participate in next year's campus recruitment, but she has never done it before. Start with a three-minute comparison. Open two new conversations. In the first, send only this sentence: "How do I conduct campus recruitment?" In the second, send the first four steps of Prompt B. View the two responses side by side, and count how many specific steps, timelines, and role assignments the deep question adds. The additions are usually sequence, trade-offs, and examples.

Prompt B: Five Steps to Get You Started

Prompt B consists of five steps: Teach only the most critical 20%; Create eight knowledge cards, each with a name, explanation, and example; Draw a text flowchart with one step per line; Provide three thinking frameworks; Finally, test me one question at a time. Only the first four steps are provided in class; step 5 is reserved for after class, to be executed after you say "Start testing me." The check criteria are: all three elements (name, explanation, example) are present on the cards, the flowchart is understandable, and during testing, you answer at least one question incorrectly.

The Crash Course Card consists of four components

The Crash Course Card consists of four components: eight knowledge cards, each with a name, a one-sentence explanation, and a workplace example; one text-based flowchart, with one step per line; three practical thinking frameworks; and finally, a series of test questions. After getting started, the common follow-up questions are only three: Why do it this way? What if the conditions changed? Please give a specific example.

Exercise C: Dig Deeper, Ask It to Shift Perspectives

Exercise C is digging deeper. The scenario involves project manager He Lei, who wants to change weekly project status meetings to biweekly. Start with a one-minute comparison, reading only the first sentence. Dialogue 1 directly asks if the idea is good, and it will likely say it is a thought worth considering. Dialogue 2 asks it to play the opposition, listing the five strongest arguments without agreeing or starting with affirmation before pivoting; it lists the consequences directly. If you want the truth, switch to a question format that prevents it from simply agreeing.

List of Opposition Arguments: Common Examples

A list of opposition arguments, with common examples including: problems are exposed later, cross-departmental dependencies are delayed, new members struggle to keep up, status updates become a mere formality, and ad-hoc decisions lack clear ownership. There should be at least two points you hadn't considered before, and each must include specific consequences, not just 'it might not be good.' Opposing views are for inspiration, not conclusion. You make the final call on whether to adopt them.

Digging for Blind Spots: Three-Layer Questioning

The final digging method is three-layer questioning. Layer 1: What is being done on the surface? He Lei's meetings are superficially about reducing meetings. Layer 2: The real problem to solve is timely information flow. Layer 3: Identify assumptions that seem valid but may not be. He Lei assumes everyone will update the shared spreadsheet on time and carefully. If you hadn't realized such an assumption before, this question is worth asking.

Exercise D: Five Fragmented Questions, Combined into One Statement

Practice D: Manage your 'internal energy.' Every word costs a bit of energy, and long conversations, images, and large files are the most expensive. Administrative Specialist Lin Yue asked five fragmented questions: Write a notice about the Mid-Autumn Festival holiday, three days off, reminding staff to secure valuables, with a relaxed tone, under 100 words. Combine these five fragments into one complete instruction and rewrite it using the four key elements. Fill in any required dates yourself; do not let the AI make them up.

Reference Answer: Ask clearly in one go.

The reference answer sends it all at once: Audience is all employees, context is a three-day holiday with specific dates filled in by you and a reminder to secure valuables, format is under 100 words, relaxed tone, no exclamation marks, no title. Fill in any required dates yourself. The check criterion is that sending it once yields a ready-to-use version, all four elements are present, and there are no blanks left for the AI to guess.

Assignment: Instruction Cards, Crash-Course Cards, and Optional Checklist

There are two mandatory assignments. First, the Four-Element Summary Card: choose a real, minor incident, write a complete summary using the four elements, and attach your reply. Then, post an incomplete sentence once, place both replies side by side, and write one sentence explaining the difference. Second, the Quick-Grow Business Card: create eight cards plus one flowchart, then pick one step. Use B2 questioning to identify three common mistakes made by beginners, and write down what you gained after asking those questions. Optional: a list of counterarguments. Before submitting, anonymize the content: keep it under 200 words, excluding client privacy, unpublished data, passwords, and contract text.

Quiz Question 1

Take Quiz Question 1: What are the four elements of a summary? A: What to do, who it is for, the background context, and the required format and length. B: Who does it, when it is done, how much it costs, and who it is for. C: Title, body, conclusion, and signature. Choose one in your mind. The answer is A. If any element is missing, the system will automatically fill it in, usually with the most generic or even fabricated content.

Quiz Question 2

Question 2: To get genuine dissenting opinions, how should you ask? A: Is this plan really good? B: Please act as someone opposing this plan and list the five strongest reasons, without offering any initial praise. C: Give me a perfect evaluation. The answer is B. It tends to go along with what you say. Explicitly asking it to take the opposing side helps uncover blind spots you might have missed.

Key Takeaways

Review today's four key points. First, the Four Elements of a Brief: ensure your instructions are complete. Second, add only one sentence at a time, then verify other sections. Third, use Quick-Start Cards to onboard unfamiliar tasks. Fourth, ask it to take the opposing side to uncover blind spots. In the next lesson, we will learn scripting: writing down the sentences you repeat every time into a fixed template.

Next lesson preview

Before the next lesson, please identify the sentences you repeat every time in your Briefing Cards and bring your Quick-Start Cards, as you will need them in the next lesson. Remember the data red lines for practice: do not include client privacy, unpublished data, passwords, or contract text. If you must include them, anonymize them first. All case studies in this lesson are fictional, and numbers are for illustration only.